*If you purchase through our links, we may earn commissions at no additional cost to you.*

Ninja Vs Power XL Air Fryer – Which One Is Better?

Ninja and Power XL both are renowned brands in the air fryer industry. Both of the brands have a number of air fryer models that are popular among air fryer users. Ninja Foodi air fryer DT251, Max XL, Dual zone, and Power XL Vortex, Maxx Classic are among the models that users tend to compare often. In this article, I am going to compare the air fryers and air fryer ovens of the two brands. After reading this, you can make a better decision about these air fryers.

You may also be interested to know about the differences between Ninja and COSORI air fryers.

Ninja Max XL Vs Power XL Maxx

Table of comparison

FeaturesPowerXL Air FryerNinja Max XL
ModelMaxx ClassicMax XL
Capacity7 qt5.5 Quart
Dimension (inch)16 x 14.2 x 1414 x 11 x 14.75
Weightunknown11 lbs
TemperatureUp to 400F105F to 450F
Power1700W1750 W
First ArrivalAug-2020Jul 5, 2019
Cooking Presets77
Color VarientsBlackBlack/ Gray
Control PanelDigital touchDigital Touch
Suitable for4 persons4 people

Features that are similar

Common cooking functions

Cooking functionsPower XL MaxxNinja Max XL
Air Fry
Bake
Roast
Broil

Both of the air fryers have 7 preset cooking functions. Among them, 4 functions are in common. The table above shows the common functions between the competing air fryer models.

Other similarities

The color of both of the air fryers is similar. Both of them are black with a glossy finish. Apart from this, both of them have a digital control panel. Although the control panel of Ninja looks way better than Power XL.

Apart from these, Ninja has a wider temperature range than Power XL. For this reason, Ninja has the option of more versatile cooking.

Dissimilarities

Cooking functions that are different

Cooking functions/ PresetsPower XL MaxxNinja Max XL
DehydrateX
Max CrispX
ReheatX
ShrimpX
ChickenX
SteakX

The table above shows the cooking functions that are not in common with these air fryers. We can see that Ninja has dehydrate, max crisp, and reheat functions that are absent in Power XL. Among these features, dehydrate is a more useful function that is not very common to an air fryer of this size. However, you can check some other cool air fryers with dehydrator function here.

Other different features

The heating element of Ninja Max XL is more powerful than Power XL. The rated power of Ninja is 1750W. It is 1700W for Power XL. A more powerful heating element ensures uniform and faster cooking.

The cooking capacity of Ninja is less than Power XL. Their capacities are 7 qt and 5.5 quarts consecutively. Both of them are perfect for cooking for a medium-size family with 4 to 5 persons. For larger capacity, you may check Ninja dual air fryers.

Advantages of Ninja Max XL ( over Power XL)

  • Ninja has the food dehydration option. This option is not present in Power XL.
  • The control panel of Ninja is bigger, user-friendly, and clean.
  • It has a wider temperature range. Therefore, have more useful cooking functions.
  • It has the Max Crisp technology that cooks faster than conventional air fryers.

Advantages of Power XL Maxx ( over Ninja)


PowerXL Air Fryer7 QT Maxx Classic

Check Latest Price
  • The price of Power XL is lower than Ninja.
  • It has more cooking capacity.
  • It came to the market later than Ninja. Therefore, it’s a newer version of an air fryer.

Which one is better?

Ninja Max XL air fryer is the winner. Although the price of this unit is a bit higher, the added value is more than the extra money you pay. It has more cooking functions, a wider temperature range, a cool control panel, and a powerful heating element. Considering all these features, I would bet on Ninja without a doubt in mind.


Ninja AF161 Max XL Air Fryer

Check Latest Price

Ninja air fryer oven DT251 vs Power XL GLA-1005

Table of comparison

FeaturesPower XL OvenNinja DT251
ModelGLA-1005DT251
Capacity12 quarts
(6 lbs of chicken)
up to 12 lbs of turkey
Dimension (inch)18 x 15 x 1517.09 x 20.22 x 13.34
Weight21.9 lbs33.8/ lbs
Temperature120F to 400F90F to 450F
Power1700W1800 W
First ArrivalNov-2020Oct-2020
Cooking Presets1010
Color VarientsStainless steelStainless steel
Control PanelDigital touchDigital touch
Suitable forLarge familyLarge family

Comparison of the features


PowerXL Air Fryer Oven 12 QT with 8-in-1 Cooking Presets

Check Latest Price

Cooking capacity

The cooking capacity of Ninja air fryer oven DT251 is almost twice as much as the Power XL oven. Power XL is a 12-quart air fryer oven that can cook up to 6 lbs of chicken in a single batch. On the other hand, DT251 can cook up to 12 lbs of turkey in one shot.

Temperature range

The temperature ranges of Ninja and Power XL are substantially good. Ninja can cook between 90F to 450F. On the other hand Power XL has a temperature range between 120F to 400F. We know that a wide temperature range is good for cooking versatility. As Ninja has a wider temperature range, it can cook in different modes.

Cooking functions

Cooking FunctionsNinja DT251Power XL 12 QT
Air Fry
Bake
Broil
Dehydrate
Roast
Toast
Reheat
Pizza
Temperature probeX
ConvectionX
BagelX
Whole roastX
RotisserieX

As I mentioned earlier, because of a wider temperature range, Ninja DT251 has a number of cooking functions including broil, dehydrate, bake, air fry, and so on.

Power XL air fryer oven also has a good number of cooking functions but it does not have convection, bagel, and few other functions. It has rotisserie cooking option that is absent in Ninja.

Control panel

Both Ninja and Power XL have a digital control panel with an LED display. Although the control panel of Ninja looks better and more composed. Both of the ovens have 10 preset cooking functions on the panel.

Other features

Ninja DT251 has the temperature probe function. With this function, you can set and monitor a specific temperature of the food. This function is useful for foods that need precise temperature control.

Price and value for money

Ninja DT251 is far more expensive than Power XL 12 quart air fryer oven. Ninja has more cooking capacity and more features compared to Power XL. Therefore, the price is of this convection oven is justified.

Ninja DT251 or Power XL 12QT – Which air fryer oven is better?

Considering the features and advantages, the Ninja DT251 air fry oven is the winner. It has a higher cooking capacity, a wider temperature range, more cooking functions, and some other cool features. Although the price of this unit is higher, I’d say that the price is balanced by the advantages it offers.


Ninja DT251 Foodi 10-in-1 Smart XL Air Fry Oven

Check Latest Price

Ninja Dual Zone Vs Power XL Dual Basket Air Fryer

Ninja and Power XL both have dual basket air fryers. In this section, we will compare both these air fryers side by side. Before further detail, let’s check the specifications of both the units.

Ninja and Power XL Dual Basket – Specifications

FeaturesPowerXL Dual BasketNinja Dual Zone
ModelVortex 10QT DualDZ401
Capacity10 QT/ 9 QT10 Quart
Dimension (inch)19 x 18 x 1517.1 x 13.9 x 12.8
Weight23 lbs19.8 lbs
Temperature90F to 400F105F to 450F
Power1700W1690 W
First ArrivalJan-2022Aug-2021
Cooking Presets86
Color VarientsBlackDark Gray S/S
Control PanelDigital touchDigital + manual knob
Suitable forLarge familyLarge family

Feature comparison between Ninja and Power XL dual basket

Capacity

Both of the models have a 10-quart cooking capacity. Both of them are good for cooking for a large family. However, Ninja DZ401 has an 8-quart version as a smaller option. On the other hand, Power XL also has a 9-quart variant as well.

Temperature range

Power XL dual basket air fryer can cook between 90F to 400F. Ninja has a wider temperature range. It can cook between 105F to 450F.

Power of the heating element

Heating elements are the hearts of the air fryers. More power is better for uniform and quicker cooking. Power XL dual basket air fryer has a heating element with 1700W rated power. On the other hand, the rated power for the Ninja Dual basket air fryer is almost the same – 1695W.

Control panel

Both Ninja and Power XL Dual basket air fryers have digital control panels with preset cooking functions. The number of preset functions for Ninja is 6. On the other hand, it is 8 for Power XL dual basket air fryer.

Cooking functions

FunctionsPower XL Dual BasketNinja DZ401
Air Fry
Bake
Broil
Dehydrate
Roast

Although Ninja has a wider temperature range, both of the air fryers provide almost similar cooking functions. Both of them can dehydrate. However, the output of the broil function of Ninja is far better as it can go up to 450F.

Advantages of Ninja Dual Zone Over Power XL Dual Basket


Ninja DZ401 Foodi 10 Quart 6-in-1 DualZone XL

Check Latest Price
  • It has a wider temperature range.
  • As it can go up to 450F, it gives better at high-temperature cooking.

However, you may also check other Ninja dual-zone air fryers such as DZ550 and DZ201.

Advantages of Power XL Dual Basket over Ninja Dual Zone

  • It has more preset cooking functions than Ninja.
  • The price of the Power XL dual basket air fryer is better than Ninja.
  • It provides better value for money.

Ninja or Power XL Dual air fryer – which one is better?

From the above side-by-side comparison, we can see that the Power XL dual basket air fryer is clearly ahead of Ninja. Although Ninja DZ401 has a wider temperature range, the value for money of Power XL is better. It has a better price but still has almost all the cooking functions that are present in Ninja. Therefore, if I were to make a decision between these two, I’d choose the Power XL Dual Basket air fryer.


PowerXL Vortex 10-qt Dual Basket Air Fryer

Check Latest Price

Ninja AF101 4 QT Air Fryer

  • You can cook with up to 75 percent less fat with the Ninja AF101 Air Fryer.
  • The wide temperature range (105 degrees Fahrenheit to 400 degrees Fahrenheit) allows you to gently remove moisture from foods or quickly cook and crisp foods with convection heat.
  • The 4 quart ceramic coated nonstick basket and crisper plate fit 2 pounds of french fries.
  • The unit is dishwasher safe for easy cleaning.
  • You can dehydrate foods with the Ninja AF101 Air Fryer to create flat, chip like dehydrated foods for fun, homemade snacks.

Ninja AF101 Air Fryer, 4 Qt

Check Latest Price

Ninja SP301

  • The dual heat technology allows you to sear and crisp at the same time.
  • The increased height capacity allows you to cook a full 2-lb roast.
  • The maximum versatility allows you to cook a variety of foods in one appliance.
  • The less fat feature allows you to eat all of your air fried favorites guilt-free.
  • The faster cooking time allows you to have your food ready in 60 seconds.

Ninja SP301 Dual Heat Air Fry

Check Latest Price

Power XL 5.3 Quart Air Fryer

  • The Power XL Air Fryer cooks food using turbo cyclonic air instead of oil, so your meals are healthier.
  • You can cook all of your favorite fast foods in the Air Fryer with fewer calories from added cooking fat/oil.
  • The Air Fryer gives you the same crispy fried taste and texture that you love without all the oil and grease.
  • The digital touchscreen and 7 one-touch easy pre-sets make it easy to use the Power XL Air Fryer.
  • The Power XL Air Fryer comes with a cookbook so you can get started cooking right away.

Power Air Fryer XL 5.3 Quart

Check Latest Price

Power XL Vortex Air Fryer Oven

  • The Power XL Vortex Air Fryer Oven can be used for multiple purposes, including air frying, broiling, baking, roasting, dehydrating, and reheating.
  • There are 10 one-touch programs that make it easy to cook various foods, including French fries, steak, chicken, fish, shrimp, bake, roast, dehydrating, pizza, and reheat.
  • The Power XL Vortex Air Fryer Oven uses true air frying technology, with a heat element and fan working together to deliver super heated, vortex air.
  • The Power XL Vortex Air Fryer Oven comes with an oil tray, 3 air flow racks, rotisserie spit, fetch tool, recipe booklet, and instruction manual.
  • The Power XL Vortex Air Fryer Oven is 15.15″H x 12.68″W x 15.03″L and 1700 watts. It has a 39-in. cord length and comes in the model no. PXLAFP-10Q.

PowerXL 10 QT Vortex Air Fryer Pro Oven

Check Latest Price

Ninja Vs Power XL – FAQ

Which brand has more air fryer models?

If we consider the standalone air fryer option, then Power XL has more air fryer models than Ninja. But Ninja has more multi-functional air fryer models. For example, there are a number of Ninja Foodi models that have air fryer functions along with other functionalities.

Which brand is better for a large family?

If you are living in a large family, then I’d suggest a Ninja Foodi that has more cooking capacity and multiple functions. Ninja DT201 or DT251 can be a good choice for a family consisting of 4 or more members. Power XL 10 quart or 12 quart air fryers are good options if your budget is limited.

What is the best air fryer oven between these two brands?

From the experience and review of the users, we can see that Ninja SP301, SP101, DT251, DT201 are relatively popular air fryer ovens that have multiple functions other than air frying.

Does Ninja or Power XL have air fryer and pressure cooker combo?

Both Ninja and Power XL have air fryer and pressure cooker combo. For example, Ninja FD401 is the most popular air fryer pressure cooker combination.

Does Ninja or Power XL have air fryer dehydrator combo?

Both Ninja and Power XL have air fryer dehydrator combo. Ninja DT251, SP101, and SP301 have dehydrator functions. On the other hand, Power XL 10 quart and 12 quart air fryer have dehydrator functions as well.

Leave a Comment